May I second that! And thanks for a very interesting post. The second lot of responses were a bit shaky on the tuning front. I thought this odd, especially as they had got the Dove so well tuned. Maybe they had assumed a 'repertoire staple' would be OK. But it's very good to hear your appraisal of the thriving musical community at Sheffield (it is possible to be a socialist and love church music!) and the energy of the choirs. Indeed, the choir we heard on Weds was very well and sensitively directed. Do please join in the cut-and-thrust from now on, Pegasus.Pegasus, welcome to the Forum in general and The Choir in particular.