The Reply to Thread and Reply options

[Bert Coules]

Well Don, I just switched to Standard Editor - Extra formatting controls but my icons are still refusing to dangle. I feel quite deprived.

[Don Petter]

Well Don, I just switched to Standard Editor - Extra formatting controls but my icons are still refusing to dangle. I feel quite deprived.

Bert,

Well, it's obviously still a bit strange. Presumably any setting should still give sensible results. Anyway, I no longer feel deprived, and I can at least dangle or not to choice, depending on the weather.

Thanks for your help, including the mysteries of the bucket, which may come in useful.

[french frank]

Well Don, I just switched to Standard Editor - Extra formatting controls but my icons are still refusing to dangle. I feel quite deprived.

And Standard is the default, so I think most people would be using it.

I am minded, btw, to restore Quick Reply this evening. We've kept this thread going in the What's New? display for two days and I don't see too many people racing over to have their say. So we have one strongly against (Curalach), balanced by one distinctly in favour (Bert) and two hovering, sort of in favour (Don,I think) or preferring QR (moi). Mmmmm?

[Bert Coules]

It wouldn't bother me unduly if Quick Reply was to be reinstated. As you say, I do like the current arrangement but a larger text box is only a single click away (if I remember) and clicking one button is not exactly a burdensome task.

Interesting though that no-one other than the four of us commenting here has entered the discussion. Did no other users notice the change? Or did they simply not care? Or perhaps did they not care enough to be bothered to say so?

[Don Petter]

I am minded, btw, to restore Quick Reply this evening. We've kept this thread going in the What's New? display for two days and I don't see too many people racing over to have their say. So we have one strongly against (Curalach), balanced by one distinctly in favour (Bert) and two hovering, sort of in favour (Don,I think) or preferring QR (moi). Mmmmm?

Keep 'em guessing, I say!

Actually, although I am very loth to upset my new friend Bert, I was quite happy before, and it did give more choice at the point of sale, so to speak. The only slight advantage that I can see of the present state is that it encourages (though not forces) posters to quote from their target post, making for more clarity in following a thread. (Particularly if one is catching up later on an existing thread.) The risk of people quoting too much unnecessary text may well offset this, though.

[Don Petter]

Interesting though that no-one other than the four of us comenting here has entered the discussion. Did no other users notice the change? Or did they simply not care? Or perhaps did they not care enough to be bothered to say so?

Perhaps it was just stunned silence, as from unexpectedly seeing women wrestling in mud?

[Bert Coules]

There are women wrestling in mud on this site? Two comments:

1. Where?

2. My word, Radio 3 must be improving if that sort of thing is relevant to their output.

[Don Petter]

There are women wrestling in mud on this site? Two comments:

1. Where?

2. My word, Radio 3 must be improving if that sort of thing is relevant to their output.

Not real women I'm afraid, just similes. What I meant was they were remaining aloof and faintly amused at the sight of the four of us thrashing around getting ever deeper in the mire.

[Bert Coules]

Yes, I suppose that's entirely possible. I've never really looked at the smilies, I'm afraid, but now I have and I still can't find any mud wrestling. But then it took me a while to work out what llabwons are, so perhaps I'm just being slow today.

[subcontrabass]

And Standard is the default, so I think most people would be using it.

I am minded, btw, to restore Quick Reply this evening. We've kept this thread going in the What's New? display for two days and I don't see too many people racing over to have their say. So we have one strongly against (Curalach), balanced by one distinctly in favour (Bert) and two hovering, sort of in favour (Don,I think) or preferring QR (moi). Mmmmm?

On balance, after experiencing both options, I would like to see Quick Reply reinstated.